Teachers, please don’t teach

Impact of Covid-19 on education

Online class in progress (Pic: Anu Agrawal)

2020 has been full of uncertainty. The pandemic and subsequent lockdown have had us struggling to adjust to changes like never before. First it was days, then weeks, then months. Now we are not even sure.


Reliable, useful journalism needs your support.

Over 600 readers have donated over the years, to make articles like this one possible. We need your support to help Citizen Matters sustain and grow. Please do contribute today. Donate now


There’s a meme doing the rounds on social media these days, about the most widely asked questions right now.

Received on Whatsapp

Those of us who are working from home and attending virtual meetings will be quite familiar with the last two questions. In fact, so will our children, who have been having virtual school for the last several weeks.

Every weekday, we ensure that our children are glued to the computers or mobile phones for their 8:00 a.m. to 1:00 p.m classes. Classes/lectures are of 30-45 minutes, with most of the time going in the teacher requesting the children to pay attention or stop talking or switch on the video or some such instruction. It’s just like a normal school day, except that it isn’t normal. It’s exhausting for the teacher, for the students and for the parents too.

(Pic: Anu Agrawal)

For the children who are accustomed to attending tuition classes, the day’s ordeal is not over even after school hours. At least 2-3 hours are spent in coaching classes that are also being held online. These supplementary classes are not just for clearing doubts and understanding concepts. They’re to achieve near perfection that will ensure the golden 95% marks, without which they (and their parents) think that they will not succeed in life.

We send our children to school not only to study, but also to learn what we call social skills – how to mix with others, make friends, communicate, adjust and share. Teaching a chapter from the text book can be done online, but how will children share their tiffins or sit in the library with their best buddies or run in the corridors or kick footballs, virtually? These are the things that make children wake up in the morning to go to school/college. They help children cope with academics and keep them happy.

As a parent and a teacher, I can see the stress building up in children. Stress can have a positive impact when it helps to avoid danger or meet a deadline. The stress brought on by studies, the stress to achieve in these trying circumstances, is causing frustration and anger and a lot of unpleasantness. Teachers are stressed too. We are striving for normalcy, but at what cost?

Many parents are not keen to send their children back to school for the rest of the year – not until the virus goes away or a vaccine comes out. Realistically thinking, children will not be going back to school for the year academic year of 2020-21. So this stress is going to continue for many more months. Possibly longer.

A full year of happiness is taken away from our children’s lives. Can we not empathise with them and take the stress of marks away?

We have before us the opportunity to shift from the marks rat-race to pragmatic thinking. This is the right time to change our attitude towards education. This is the right time to help our children realise their potential, and not just in academics. Towards this I’d think it appropriate to declare this year a ‘zero year’, meaning teaching and learning will happen to the extent possible, but there will not be grading or exams or promotion to the next class. Instead of academics, focus can be turned to life basics.

Nature has warned us through this virus that we need to return to basics. Basic skills are what our children need to survive. Let them be taught skills that they can learn without stress. Now the question is which skills? What all can be done in a closed environment?

Schools can do activities around critical thinking. They can have debates, elocution, writing, painting, dancing, photography, film making. They can do small modules on marketing, finance and communication. They can hold quizzes. They can get children to collaborate for some of these. They can encourage the children to complete certain household tasks – such as cooking, washing vessels, ironing, stitching. There are many ways of engaging with the children in a way that they look forward to their school day, albeit at home.

Some parents are worried about the children losing one or two years of their academic lives. The curriculum can be adjusted so that this need not be the case. Even otherwise, as all of us know from our own lives that a couple of years makes no difference in the long run. In countries like Singapore and Thailand, boys have to mandatorily get army training after school, for two years. They do not consider these as lost years.

All this while, I’ve had in mind, children from families that have the infrastructure that supports virtual learning – computers/ smartphones, internet connectivity, electricity. There are thousands of children who do not have access to these. For them there is the mental trauma of feeling left behind. A zero year will also benefit students for whom there is no alternative to classroom learning.  

These are extraordinary times that will go down in history. Let us not be in a hurry to return to school.


WE WANT TO THANK YOU
for reading Citizen Matters, of course. It would be fantastic to be able to thank you for supporting us as well. For 12 years we have strived to bring you trustworthy and useful information about our cities. Because informed citizens are crucial to make a better city. Support Citizen Matters today.

DONATE NOW



About Anu Agrawal 1 Article
Anu Agrawal is a Chartered Accountant, with over 20 years of experience in the field of consultancy, teaching and career counselling. She runs her own teaching institute in Mumbai.

31 Comments

  1. Well thought out timely advice to parents and students not to take stress or strains for just education at the moment. Now the priority is good health with proper social grooming of our children

    • Agree to these insights. Academic education is not what we need at the moment. Basic life skills and understanding of the situation and environment around us is more important.

  2. Very true and apt in the current scenario…all of us need to change with the changing circumstances and adapt… that’s the only way forward…wonderful article, Anu…

  3. Beautifully explained the need of present teaching environment and also covered all the aspects of life in the article for parents, teacher’s and students.

  4. Absolutely agree.It should be declared ‘0’ Year Academically in order to ease out the pressure of rat run and make
    them stress free.

  5. The past 15 or more years spent in improving the literacy in India gone to a complete waste, the problems of child abuse, child marriage, mental health issues given no thought at all. Just the voice of a small percentage of economically comfortable city residents,decisions cannot be based on narrow considerations

  6. Very well said.Why not utilize this time for doing things which we have never been able to do with kids.Engaging children with some family bonding games ,relaxing talks& fun learning activities instead of being glued to screens.Let this be a memorable time for them.

  7. Good thought. But it should come from the Top, the HRD, The atate education departments, CBSE …all must be ready to accept this and ask schools to implement it. Schools do what the Government of the state and county says it to do.

  8. Good thought. But it should come from the Top, the HRD, The state education departments, CBSE …all must be ready to accept this and ask schools to implement it. Schools do what the Government of the state and county asks it to do.

    • Very correctly said.its good time to teach values to this generation. The importance of joint families is known now as children are getting time to sit with their grandparents and chat with them in turn they are getting to know about their extended family members.

  9. Nice article. But no one understands the stress n pain that the teachers are going through. To take an online lecture means before that so many hours they have to sit to prepare ppts. All unaided teachers too don’t have all equipments that are required for online perfect teaching. And moreover several unaided teachers are going without salary since the month of April or May. Still no salary. Aren’t the teachers human beings, don’t they need money to survive, don’t they have a family.. Every teacher cannot turnout to sell vegetables or fish or idli sambar.. Very pathetic conditions of unaided teachers in a huge democratic country lik India..

    • I agree completely…..how r the teachers suppose to run their families and carry out their responsibilities.
      The government is not waiving of anything…talk abt the electricity bill, the rent or the EMI’s and so many other basic things.
      I am a teacher and self dependent…what am I suppose to do as we are anyways getting 50% of the said salary.
      Is it going to be zero now???
      Who is going to be responsible for our situations because clearly the government is not going to be.

  10. Yup correct. This is gonna go down as the biggest hoax scamdemic by which v r deceived. Don’t give into the fear mongering by the WHO, bill Gates, China, etc

  11. Very correct words madam but who will understand all forcing everything on the children but not understanding the mental condition of the child

  12. Well summarised. Both as a teacher and a parent, I see this daily struggle.The school is also struggling to give its best and meet demands of parents.

Comments are closed.